Who was eliminated and who arrived on the beach in Bachelor in Paradise season 10, episode 4? Details explored

Bachelor in Paradise season 10, episode 4 aired on July 21, 2025, and featured both eliminations and new arrivals that shifted the dynamics on the beach. The rose ceremony at the end of the episode sent three men home—RJ, Jack, and CK.

Meanwhile, four new contestants joined the cast: Gary Levingston from The Golden Bachelorette, Nancy Hulkower and Faith Martin from The Golden Bachelor, and Lea Cayanan from Joey Graziadei’s season of The Bachelor.

The episode opened with Gary’s arrival, who quickly made an impression and took Leslie Fhima on a romantic date.

Later, Nancy and Lea arrived after the rose ceremony, followed by Faith, who made a dramatic entrance on horseback. These additions continued the show’s generational twist, bringing more senior contestants into the mix.

Meanwhile, existing couples faced new challenges. Kat and Dale had a conflict that nearly derailed their connection, and April made a bold move by giving her rose to Jonathon instead of one of the older men.

Her comment—“to heck with the Golden Guys”—captured the shifting loyalties as the cast prepared for more changes.

Gary's arrival and new connections shake up Bachelor in Paradise season 10

 

 

 

 

View this post on Instagram

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

A post shared by Bachelor in Paradise (@bachelorinparadise)

Gary Levingston joined Bachelor in Paradise and quickly made a strong impression. After talking to several women, he asked Leslie Fhima on a date.

Their night included dancing in the rain and a long, personal conversation. Both opened up about their life experiences and what they were looking for in a relationship.

Natascha Hardee, who had connected with Gary earlier in the day, was disappointed not to be chosen for the date. However, she later gave her rose to Gary during the ceremony.

Leslie, who had also considered Gary as a top connection, decided to give her rose to Kim instead.

After the rose ceremony, two more contestants arrived: Nancy Hulkower from The Golden Bachelor and Lea Cayanan from Joey Graziadei’s season.

Near the end of the episode, Faith Martin made her entrance on horseback, catching the group off guard.

This episode of Bachelor in Paradise marked a turning point as the number of Golden Gals began to outpace the Golden Guys.

With new personalities entering the mix and existing connections tested, the newcomers set the stage for more shifting dynamics in the weeks ahead.

April's decision stuns the group in Bachelor in Paradise rose ceremony

The rose ceremony in episode 4 of Bachelor in Paradise happened after some emotional talks and a big argument between Kat and Dale. Kat found out that Dale had kissed Alli Jo, so she confronted him.

Dale said he had ended things with Alli Jo, but Kat still thought about giving her rose to Jonathon instead. In the end, she stayed with Dale, which left Jonathon in danger of being sent home.

The most surprising moment came from April. She had been close to Jack Lencioni, but instead of giving him her rose, she gave it to Jonathon. Before doing so, she said, “to heck with the Golden Guys.”

Her choice shocked the group and led to three men—RJ, Jack, and CK—going home without roses.

Here’s how the roses were distributed:

• Parisa to Brian
• Bailey to Jeremy
• Alexe to Andrew
• Natascha to Gary
• Leslie to Kim
• Kathy to Keith
• Jess to Spencer
• Jill to Sean
• Kat to Dale
• April to Jonathon

The results left the Golden Guys outnumbered by the Golden Gals, introducing new challenges for those remaining.

April’s move shifted the power dynamics heading into the next week, as contestants reassess alliances and prepare for more surprises.

Stay tuned for more updates.

​