Rookie eliminates former champion Rogan O’Connor in The Challenge: Vets & New Threats season 41 premiere

MTV’s The Challenge: Vets & New Threats premiered its 41st season on July 30, 2025, with returning host TJ Lavin leading a brand-new format that paired veteran players with newcomers.

After multiple seasons without rookies, the show introduced a fresh group aiming to prove themselves against some of the most experienced names in franchise history.

Among them was Justin Hinsley, who made a strong impression by eliminating former champion Rogan O’Connor in the very first episode.

Rogan returned after a five-year break but faced early trouble after being paired with fellow Brit Adrienne Naylor.

The duo’s poor performance in the daily challenge placed them at the bottom of the rankings, sending them directly into the elimination round.

Rogan chose to face Justin, likely expecting a physical advantage. However, the rookie’s agility and strategy helped him overcome Rogan’s strength, leading to a surprising upset.

The premiere also revealed several twists in the format, including random gender-based eliminations, shifting partnerships, and a new “hangnail” role for unpaired contestants.

With both familiar faces and new threats in the game, the season began with high stakes and unexpected outcomes.

Former champ exits early after elimination twist in The Challenge: Vets & New Threats

 

 

 

 

View this post on Instagram

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

A post shared by The Challenge (@thechallenge)

The episode’s elimination round saw Rogan O’Connor, a previous winner, face off against rookie Justin Hinsley in The Challenge. Rogan had aimed to use his return as a chance to re-establish himself in the game.

He formed a quick connection with Izzy Fairthorne but was instead partnered with Adrienne Naylor. Their pairing struggled in the daily challenge and finished last, putting them up for elimination.

Rogan chose Justin as his opponent, expecting to win with sheer strength. However, the challenge relied on speed and technique, giving Justin an edge.

Despite a visible size difference, Justin used balance and leverage to win the round. His performance shocked many in the house and sent Rogan home on night one.

According to the episode, Rogan’s elimination came as a surprise to the veterans, and it reinforced how unpredictable the game could be this season.

TJ Lavin reminded everyone that performance would outweigh reputation, and one rookie had already proven that. As Justin stayed in the game, Adrienne’s future remained unclear under the show’s “hangnail” rule.

New format, new rules, and new pairings in The Challenge: Vets & New Threats

The Challenge premiere introduced a revamped format combining individual gameplay with rotating partnerships.

At the start of the episode, TJ Lavin revealed that eliminations would be based on a random gender draw each time.

This week, it was a men’s elimination, meaning male players were vulnerable while their female partners were temporarily safe.

Johnny “Bananas” Devenanzio and Dee Valladares won the daily challenge after collecting the most balls in a muddy pit challenge.

Dee had initially been hesitant about teaming up with Bananas, but the win granted them safety and the power to save another pair.

They chose to protect a second team from elimination, following the season’s new twist.

The format also introduced the concept of “hangnails,” where the partner of an eliminated contestant is left without a teammate.

It is still unclear what this means going forward, but TJ mentioned that new pairings would be assigned, suggesting that partners may rotate frequently.

The changes set the stage for a fast-paced season where alliances and matchups could shift with every episode. With 29 players remaining, the competition now moves forward under a system designed to keep everyone on edge.

Stay tuned for more updates.