Peacemaker season 2 takes a bold step with a controversial move that could shape the direction of the show

After the first season established James Gunn’s blend of dark comedy, violence, and heartfelt storytelling, Peacemaker season 2 pushes into riskier territory with higher stakes and stranger twists. The series — a creation that grew out of Gunn’s expanding DCU roadmap — follows Christopher Smith (John Cena), a morally fraught antihero conscripted into ARGUS missions while wrestling with trauma, duty, and a warped sense of honor. Drawing from the comics’ mix of satire and noir, it balances grotesque action and slapstick absurdity with surprisingly tender character work, anchored by the ragtag 11th Street Kids who humanize Smith. 

This installment widens the show’s mythology with cybernetic secrets, dimension-hopping stakes, and teases of larger Gotham ties, all while keeping the emotional core intact: a man trying to be better even when his impulses keep undermining him. Strong supporting work and a willingness to subvert expectations keep momentum high.

Sasha Bordeaux’s Shocking Transformation in Peacemaker Season 2

One of the most talked-about elements of Peacemaker season 2 episode 5 is the revelation about Sasha Bordeaux. In the comics, Sasha was first introduced as Bruce Wayne’s bodyguard, later evolving into a trusted ally who uncovered his secret identity as Batman. Her journey eventually led her into Checkmate, where she became a cyborg—retaining her humanity while gaining cybernetic powers.

In Gunn’s reimagining, however, Sasha begins the series as a seemingly loyal ARGUS agent reporting directly to Rick Flag Sr., portrayed by Frank Grillo. By Episode 5, the façade shatters: during a tense standoff, her cybernetic eye activates, giving her the ability to analyze Peacemaker’s vulnerabilities with chilling precision. The reveal confirms that she isn’t fully human but a cybernetically enhanced survivor of a tragic plane crash, rebuilt by ARGUS.

This twist is both a nod to her comic book OMAC transformation and a reinvention that grounds her firmly in Gunn’s gritty DCU. It’s also controversial, as it redefines a Batman-adjacent character within the context of Peacemaker, potentially altering her ties to Gotham’s Dark Knight. Gunn has turned her into both a dangerous adversary and a potential key to future DCU developments.

Recap of Peacemaker season 2 episode 5

Episode 5 of Peacemaker season 2 delivers multiple shocks beyond Sasha’s reveal. The episode, titled Back to the Suture, begins with Peacemaker being cornered and beaten by ARGUS forces under Rick Flag Sr's command. Emilia Harcourt, while initially suspected of betrayal, ultimately warns him of the danger. Despite her efforts, Chris’s longing for closure leads him into a trap.

Thanks to John Economos and Harcourt, Chris narrowly escapes. But in a surprising twist, he decides to leap into an alternate dimension rather than remain in his own reality. This choice underscores his complicated psyche: while he has found friendship in the “11th Street Kids,” the chance to reunite with his father and brother in another reality proves too tempting to ignore.

Meanwhile, the team resolves to bring Chris back, despite the risks of dimension-hopping. Eagly, revealed to be the legendary Prime Eagle, remains at his side in the alternate world. The closing sequences hint at bigger challenges ahead, including ARGUS’s determination to capture him and the potential involvement of figures like Lex Luthor to navigate the dimensional chaos.

Episode 5 thus sets up an explosive second half of the season. Between Sasha’s cybernetic transformation, Chris’s alternate reality dilemma, and ARGUS’s growing pursuit, Gunn has left viewers with a tangled web of emotional stakes and high-concept storytelling.

With Peacemaker season 2’s latest episode, the series pushes boundaries by reimagining Sasha Bordeaux and introducing alternate dimensions, all while teasing possible connections to Batman and the wider DCU. The controversial yet intriguing changes prove that James Gunn isn’t afraid to take risks with beloved characters.