How does Murdaugh: Death in the Family compare to the real-life Murdaugh family story?

Hulu’s Murdaugh: Death in the Family unravels the chilling saga of the Murdaugh family, a South Carolina legal dynasty shattered by scandal, murder and betrayal. Inspired by journalist Mandy Matney’s Murdaugh Murders Podcast, the series dramatizes the realblife 2023 conviction of Alex Murdaugh for the brutal murders of his wife Maggie and son Paul at their isolated hunting estate. 

Co-created by Erin Lee Carr and Michael D. Fuller, the show stars Jason Clarke as Alex, a once respected attorney whose lies unravelled a legacy spanning generations. But how faithfully does this scripted drama reflect the complex reality? By weaving Matney’s meticulous reporting with emotional depth, the series captures the essence of a family’s downfall while taking creative liberties to highlight human truths. 

From the 2019 boat crash that killed Mallory Beach to Alex’s courtroom admission of deception, the show balances factual anchors with poignant storytelling. It explores privilege- manipulation and the ripple effects of choices, offering a gripping lens into a case that captivated the nation. 

Murdaugh: Death in the Family mirrors reality by balancing fact and fiction

The real Murdaugh story is a labyrinth of tragedy and crime, beginning with a 2019 boat crash that killed 19-year-old Mallory Beach, sparked by Paul Murdaugh’s drunken recklessness. This incident exposed cracks in the family’s pristine facade, leading to the 2021 murders of Paul and Maggie at their Moselle property in Colleton County.

Alex convicted in 2023, faced additional charges for financial crimes including defrauding clients like Gloria Satterfield’s sons. Murdaugh: Death in the Family anchors itself in these events, with Jason Clarke and Patricia Arquette delivering nuanced performances as Alex and Maggie. The series draws heavily from Matney’s reporting, depicting the Murdaughs’ dominance in Murdaugh Country, where their law firm and prosecutorial legacy held sway for decades.

However, the show embraces story truth, as Fuller describes, streamlining complex details for narrative clarity. For instance, real-life figures like Olivia, Matney’s initial source, are merged into the character of Morgan Doughty to simplify the plot. Alex’s courtroom quote in Episode 1: Family Tradition,

“Oh, what a tangled web we weave”

directly mirroring his real-life acknowledgement of lying to investigators, a moment Carr calls a “fascinating cross” of self-awareness and deceit.

The series also entertains the possibility of Maggie wanting to leave Alex based on Marian's testimony, which stated that Maggie did not want to go back to Moselle the night she died. These creative choices heighten emotional stakes while maintaining plausible motivations grounded in earthly reality; this gives the drama an emotional heft without going too far from the observable world.

Murdaugh: Death in the Family distinguishes itself by prioritizing the victims’ humanity - a focus driven by Matney’s victim-forward journalism. The series weaves in intimate details of Mallory Beach’s passion for dogs, Gloria Satterfield’s maternal bond with Paul and Buster, or Stephen Smith’s quirky habit of making cat treats, drawn from real accounts to honor those lost. 

Unlike sensationalized true crime narratives, Carr and Fuller avoid exploitative tropes emphasizing the psychological toll of the Murdaughs’ actions. Rather than depicting Alex as a cliché villain, he is shown as a nefarious character who is flawed and destroyed by lies, which also reflects Matney’s reporting on the family’s power and privilege.

The narrative wraps up with Alex getting convicted which provides a consummate resolution without needing to explain his appeal for a new trial or the status of the investigation into Stephen Smith’s death in 2015.

Murdaugh: Death in the Family is currently streaming on Hulu. The first three episodes are available now and will new episodes will be released weekly on Wednesdays until November 19, 2025.

Stay tuned for more such updates!