What is Carol's theory about the synovial fluid in Pluribus?

Pluribus, the latest sci-fi thriller from Vince Gilligan, the mind behind "Breaking Bad" and "Better Call Saul," hit Apple TV+ on November 7, 2025. The nine-episode first season drops two episodes weekly on Fridays, with the finale set for December 26. 

The show centers on Carol Sturka, played by Rhea Seehorn, who is a romantasy novelist left isolated after a global event called "the Joining", an alien DNA sequence spreads via a deep-space signal, turning most of humanity into a peaceful hive mind known as "the Others." 

This collective shares thoughts, emotions, and a strict code against harm or lies, but it enforces a creepy, enforced bliss that erases individuality. Carol, one of only 13 immune survivors worldwide, grapples with grief over her lost partner Helen while probing the hive's secrets in a deserted Albuquerque.

By episode 5, titled "Got Milk" her discoveries hint at a dark underbelly, tying into her emerging theory about a real-world human lubricant that fans speculate can be synovial fluid. Carol's suspicion grows after finding drained milk cartons and a white powder that mixes into a neutral-pH liquid matching synovial fluid's properties.

It is viscous and clear with a pH around 7.3 undiluted, dropping to 7.1 when watered down. She posits the Others extract it from the dead to create their sole sustenance, a "milk" that's recycled human essence, sustaining the hive without killing, aligning with their no-harm rule. 

This revelation, uncovered in a chilling warehouse cliffhanger, suggests the Joining's bliss relies on devouring the past, turning bodies into psychic fuel. 

Carol's theory in Pluribus episode 5: The mystery “milk” may have possible composition of synovial fluid and dead human remains

Episode 5, "Got Milk," aired early on November 26, 2025, to dodge Thanksgiving, ramping up the isolation after the hive abandons Albuquerque. Carol, reeling from dosing Zosia with truth serum in episode 4, triggering global tears and the hive's retreat, records desperate video pleas to the other survivors. She believes the hive's emotional flinch proves a reversal exists, but details elude her.

Wandering empty streets, she spots recycling bins overflowing with tiny milk cartons, all drained. Testing one, she finds the residue: a straw-yellow goo with an unfamiliar odour, neutral pH, and a slick feel.

At Duke City Dairy, she uncovers bags of white powder, barcoded to a dog food maker but rerouted by the hive. Mixing it with water replicates the liquid, confirming it's their diet staple.

Her trail leads to an Agri-Jet warehouse, a cold storage site the hive cleared for "supply consolidation." Amid pallets of veggies, she lifts a plastic tarp on a suspicious load. Her face cycles from confusion to dread—she clamps a hand over her mouth, eyes wide in revulsion, as the screen cuts to black with credits rolling.

The moment exploded online, with Reddit threads buzzing over what lay beneath. Fans drew Soylent Green comparisons, theorizing the powder is bone meal or synovial fluid extract from the Joining's victims, explaining the hive's withdrawal. They see Carol as a threat to their secret recycling operation. 

Since Synovial fluid is the clear, viscous substance that lubricates joints in the human body, it's an ultrafiltrate of blood plasma mixed with proteins like hyaluronic acid and lubricin.

This combo reduces friction during movement, nourishes cartilage, and cushions bones, with a neutral pH around 7 and a texture thinner than olive oil but sticky enough to cling.

Carol's theory posits that the hive mind isn't just sharing minds; it's recycling human bodies at a molecular level, extracting synovial fluid as a key ingredient in their sole sustenance: a mysterious "milk" that's not dairy at all.

The show doesn't name it outright, but the parallels are striking. The hive's liquid, amber-colored, with a weird odor, pH 7.1 and produced by mixing a white powder with water mirrors synovial fluid's properties.

This ties into the show's themes of resource scarcity in a post-apocalypse. The Others hoard perishables and avoid meat, opting for this engineered brew that might act as "psychic glue," enhancing their bond while evading traditional food chains. 

For episode 6, dropping December 5, 2025, speculations run wild. It may unveil the tarp's contents as vats of harvested fluid or pulverized remains. Carol could connect it to reversal: disrupting supply lines to fracture the hive. Others predict hive retaliation, with Zosia returning altered, or Manousos allying against a "cannibal cult."

Stream Pluribus exclusively on Apple TV+, with new episodes Fridays at 12 a.m. ET. Subscription starts at $9.99/month, or try a seven-day free trial. 

Stay tuned for more such updates!